From: "Dawn Gabig, Classique" <Gabig@cableone.net>
To: "Julie Rachelle" <julie.rachelle@yahoo.com>
Subject: Ian Dunbar's Bite Inhibition Article
Date: Tue, 27 Oct 2009 08:32:38 -0500
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
	boundary="----=_NextPart_000_05A5_01CA56E0.0ADE3C00"
X-Priority: 3
X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
X-Mailer: Microsoft Windows Mail 6.0.6001.18000
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.0.6001.18049

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------=_NextPart_000_05A5_01CA56E0.0ADE3C00
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

TEACHING YOUR PUPPY BITE INHIBITION
by Ian Dunbar, Ph.D., MRCVS

Taken from the AKC Gazette



In addition to selectively breeding for disposition, all dogs should be =
actively trained to be friendly and trustworthy.  It would be folly to =
sit back with the blithe assumption that a puppy dog will necessarily =
and naturally develop a super disposition, since all breeds are capable =
of being unfriendly.  Moreover, many breed standards actually forewarn =
us that certain breeds are prone to be shy, timid, nervous, suspicious, =
reserved, standoffish, protective, dominant or even =
aggressive--especially toward strangers.

Temperament training is an active process that involves a number of =
specific and essential exercises to continually modify the puppy's =
developing temperament to ensure that it always remains friendly toward =
all people.  A temperament training program has three stages:  1) =
teaching bite inhibition; 2) socializing the pup with all sorts of =
people, so that the dog likes the company and actions of people and =
would not want to bite them; 3) friendly training, which means =
specifically training the puppy dog to "act" as if it is cute and =
friendly.  This type of training is designed to assuage people's fears =
and help them feel at ease around the dog, so that they don't display =
fearful actions and mannerisms and unnecessarily spook the dog.

BITE INHIBITION
Without a doubt, teaching bite inhibition is the single most important =
item on the educational agenda of any pup.  Consequently, bite =
inhibition training should head the syllabus of any kindergarten or =
comprehensive puppy training program.  The pup must be taught to inhibit =
the force of its biting behavior so that it develops a soft mouth.  It =
must also be taught to inhibit the frequency of its now gentler =
mouthing, so that the adolescent dog learns to keep its jaws to itself =
and never mouth any person or their clothing.

It is as unrealistic to expect dogs never to be frightened or annoyed by =
people as it is to expect people never to frighten or annoy each other.  =
However, just as it is reasonable to expect people to resolve their =
disagreements without physical violence, it is both realistic and =
perfectly feasible to teach dogs never to physically harm a person when =
scared or provoked.

Dogs suffer incessant provocation from people, especially from children =
and men, and a large proportion of dogs are involved in some kind of =
aggressive altercation with humans at some time in their lives.  But in =
such instances, both the prognosis for rehabilitation and the fate of =
the dog are almost always dependent on how much damage the dog =
inflicted--that is, the dog's level of bite inhibition.

DAMAGE DONE
Ideally, all dogs should be taught never to respond aggressively to any =
kind of provocation, but this is impossible in practice, especially in =
instances of extreme and unexpected provocation.  Let's look at the =
following case histories.  In the first four, a dog was provoked and =
responded in an understandable way.  The fifth case is an exception, and =
is explained on the next page.

Case 1:  An 8-year-old struck out during a baseball game and hit the =
dog's muzzle with a baseball bat.  The dog yelped and ran.

Case 2:  A woman tripped, dropped a cup of hot chocolate over the dog =
and fell headlong into the dog's face while it was gnawing on a bone.  =
The dog nipped the woman on the cheek but did not puncture the skin.

Case 3:  A woman hurrying to answer the phone pierced the dog's thigh =
with her high-heel.  The dog bit her on the ankle, causing three =
punctures basely 1/4 inch deep.

Case 4:  A man grabbed the dog's cheeks with both hands, shook the dog =
vigorously, flipped it on its back and screamed obscenities in the dog's =
face.  The dog sliced the man's ear with two punctures--little damage =
but a lot of blood.

Case 5:  A 3-year-old toddled up to the dog and reached out to pat it on =
the head.  The dog bit the child in the face five times.

In each case, whether the scared and/or provoked dog ran, hid, growled, =
snarled, snapped, nipped, bit or savaged depended primarily on the =
degree of learned bit inhibition established in puppyhood.

Because the dogs exercised remarkable restraint and demonstrated fairly =
solid bite inhibition in the first four cases, these were resolved =
easily with basic, commonsense people education and dog training.  =
However, in the fifth case, the dog was euthanized and the child was =
physically and mentally scarred for life.  The dog had obviously not =
been socialized with children, but more damning, the dog had very little =
bite inhibition at all.  When bite inhibition is poor or nonexistent, if =
and when the dog bites, in addition to the serious injury caused to the =
victim, invariably the dog loses its life and the owner loses a =
companion, peace of mind and often a lawsuit.

INHIBIT FORCE BEFORE FREQUENCY
A puppy's needle-sharp teeth and its often rapacious penchant for biting =
are essential for the establishment of bite inhibition and the =
development of a soft mouth.  Puppy biting hurts but seldom cases =
appreciable harm.  In fact, puppy biting behavior is the way a young pup =
learns its jaws can hurt.  It is important puppies learn to inhibit the =
force of their biting before they acquire the blunt yet formidable teeth =
and strong jaws of an adolescent dog.

Although the abrupt and total curtailment of puppy biting (if possible) =
offers immediate relief to most owners, it often reflects only a =
short-term gain and does not always augur well for the future.  If the =
puppy is forbidden to bite, it will not have sufficient opportunity to =
learn that its jaws may inflict pain.  Thus, if it is ever provoked to =
bite as an adult, the resultant bite is likely to be a hard one, causing =
severe damage.  Certainly puppy biting must be controlled, but only in a =
progressive, systematic manner, whereby the pup is taught to inhibit the =
force of its bites.

To inform the puppy that biting hurts, it is not necessary to hurt, =
frighten, punish or even reprimand the pup; a simple "Ouch!" is =
sufficient.  If the pup acknowledges the "ouch" and desists, praise and =
resume playing but in a calmer manner. If the puppy ignores the =
reprimand, emphasize "OOOUUCHH!" and exit pronto.

LEARNING THROUGH PLAY
As when playing with their littermates or mom's teats and tail, puppies =
quickly learn hard bites lose playmates.  Return after one or two =
minutes time out and make up by having the puppy come, sit and calm down =
before resuming play.

Once the pup's mouthing no longer hurts, pretend it does.  Greet harder =
munches with a yelp of pseudo-pain.   The puppy will begin to get the =
idea, thinking, "Whooahh! These humans are super-sensitive.  I'll have =
to be much more gentle."  The force of the puppy's biting will =
progressively decrease until biting becomes mouthing and eventually, =
mouthing succumbs to gumming or slobbering.

Never allow the puppy to mouth human hair or clothing.  Hair and =
clothing are not innervated and therefore can feel neither pressure nor =
pain.  Allowing a pup to mouth hair, scarves, shoelaces or gloved hands =
inadvertently trains it to bite harder, extremely close to human flesh!

Once the puppy's mouthing no longer exerts any palpable pressure =
whatsoever, then and only then can you teach the pup to reduce the =
frequency of its oral proclivities.  Teach the meaning of "Off!" by =
hand-feeding kibble, so the pup may learn very gentle mouthing is okay, =
but it must stop the instant you say, "Off!"

And of course, allowing mouthing to resume is the best reward for a =
puppy that stops mouthing on request.  At this stage the puppy, or young =
adolescent dog, should never be allowed to initiate mouthing (unless =
requested to do so).

NIP IT IN THE BUD
Some dogs learn to inhibit the force and frequency of biting quickly and =
naturally, whereas for other dogs bite inhibition must be actively =
taught as a specific exercise.  After just a few weeks of instruction, =
the "mouthy" breeds and their puppies from hell characteristically =
curtail hard biting fairly quickly, since the owner is immediately aware =
of the problem and takes appropriate action and the puppy has more than =
ample opportunity to learn its biting hurts.

It may seem paradoxical, but puppies that are mouthing maniacs and/or =
puppies that grow up with children are much more likely to develop =
gentle jaws and a soft mouth as an adult.  On the other hand, shy, =
reserved and /or fearful dogs, which often do not play as much and =
therefore seldom roughhouse or bite their owners, and breeds that have =
been bred to have soft mouths, seldom present much of a puppy problem to =
their owners and therefore do not receive sufficient feedback concerning =
the power of their jaws.

All too often, when a dog has bitten severely the case history reveals =
the dog was "fine" as a puppy.  This is the major reason we go to great =
pains to encourage shy and standoffish dogs to play in puppy class.  The =
most important survival lesson for a puppy to learn is that when it =
bites, it causes pain.  Of course, the pup can only learn this lessen if =
it bites and if the bitee gives appropriate feedback.


Many of these exercises are demonstrated in Ian Dunbar's "Sirius Puppy =
Training" video and described in detail in his "Preventing Aggression" =
booklet, available from James & Kenneth Publishers, Berkeley, =
California.

------=_NextPart_000_05A5_01CA56E0.0ADE3C00
Content-Type: text/html;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD>
<META content=3D"text/html; charset=3Diso-8859-1" =
http-equiv=3DContent-Type>
<META name=3DGENERATOR content=3D"MSHTML 8.00.6001.18828">
<STYLE></STYLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff>
<DIV><FONT size=3D2 face=3DArial>
<P align=3Dcenter><B><FONT size=3D6 face=3DEurostile>TEACHING YOUR PUPPY =
BITE=20
INHIBITION</FONT><FONT size=3D5 face=3DEurostile><BR>by Ian Dunbar, =
Ph.D.,=20
MRCVS</FONT></B></P>
<P align=3Dcenter><FONT size=3D5 face=3DEurostile><B>Taken from the AKC=20
Gazette</B></FONT></P>
<P align=3Dcenter>&nbsp;</P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>In addition to selectively breeding for disposition, =
all dogs=20
should be actively trained to be friendly and trustworthy.&nbsp; It =
would be=20
folly to sit back with the blithe assumption that a puppy dog will =
necessarily=20
and naturally develop a super disposition, since all breeds are capable =
of being=20
unfriendly.&nbsp; Moreover, many breed standards actually forewarn us =
that=20
certain breeds are prone to be shy, timid, nervous, suspicious, =
reserved,=20
standoffish, protective, dominant or even aggressive--especially toward=20
strangers.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Temperament training is an active process that involves =
a number=20
of specific and essential exercises to continually modify the puppy's =
developing=20
temperament to ensure that it always remains friendly toward all =
people.&nbsp; A=20
temperament training program has three stages:&nbsp; 1) teaching bite=20
inhibition; 2) socializing the pup with all sorts of people, so that the =
dog=20
likes the company and actions of people and would not want to bite them; =
3)=20
friendly training, which means specifically training the puppy dog to =
"act" as=20
if it is cute and friendly.&nbsp; This type of training is designed to =
assuage=20
people's fears and help them feel at ease around the dog, so that they =
don't=20
display fearful actions and mannerisms and unnecessarily spook the=20
dog.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>BITE INHIBITION<BR>Without a doubt, teaching bite =
inhibition is=20
the single most important item on the educational agenda of any =
pup.&nbsp;=20
Consequently, bite inhibition training should head the syllabus of any=20
kindergarten or comprehensive puppy training program.&nbsp; The pup must =
be=20
taught to inhibit the force of its biting behavior so that it develops a =
soft=20
mouth.&nbsp; It must also be taught to inhibit the frequency of its now =
gentler=20
mouthing, so that the adolescent dog learns to keep its jaws to itself =
and never=20
mouth any person or their clothing.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>It is as unrealistic to expect dogs never to be =
frightened or=20
annoyed by people as it is to expect people never to frighten or annoy =
each=20
other.&nbsp; However, just as it is reasonable to expect people to =
resolve their=20
disagreements without physical violence, it is both realistic and =
perfectly=20
feasible to teach dogs never to physically harm a person when scared or=20
provoked.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Dogs suffer incessant provocation from people, =
especially from=20
children and men, and a large proportion of dogs are involved in some =
kind of=20
aggressive altercation with humans at some time in their lives.&nbsp; =
But in=20
such instances, both the prognosis for rehabilitation and the fate of =
the dog=20
are almost always dependent on how much damage the dog inflicted--that =
is, the=20
dog's level of bite inhibition.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>DAMAGE DONE<BR>Ideally, all dogs should be taught never =
to=20
respond aggressively to any kind of provocation, but this is impossible =
in=20
practice, especially in instances of extreme and unexpected =
provocation.&nbsp;=20
Let's look at the following case histories.&nbsp; In the first four, a =
dog was=20
provoked and responded in an understandable way.&nbsp; The fifth case is =
an=20
exception, and is explained on the next page.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Case 1:&nbsp; An 8-year-old struck out during a =
baseball game and=20
hit the dog's muzzle with a baseball bat.&nbsp; The dog yelped and=20
ran.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Case 2:&nbsp; A woman tripped, dropped a cup of hot =
chocolate=20
over the dog and fell headlong into the dog's face while it was gnawing =
on a=20
bone.&nbsp; The dog nipped the woman on the cheek but did not puncture =
the=20
skin.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Case 3:&nbsp; A woman hurrying to answer the phone =
pierced the=20
dog's thigh with her high-heel.&nbsp; The dog bit her on the ankle, =
causing=20
three punctures basely 1/4 inch deep.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Case 4:&nbsp; A man grabbed the dog's cheeks with both =
hands,=20
shook the dog vigorously, flipped it on its back and screamed =
obscenities in the=20
dog's face.&nbsp; The dog sliced the man's ear with two =
punctures--little damage=20
but a lot of blood.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Case 5:&nbsp; A 3-year-old toddled up to the dog and =
reached out=20
to pat it on the head.&nbsp; The dog bit the child in the face five=20
times.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>In each case, whether the scared and/or provoked dog =
ran, hid,=20
growled, snarled, snapped, nipped, bit or savaged depended primarily on =
the=20
degree of learned bit inhibition established in =
puppyhood.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Because the dogs exercised remarkable restraint and =
demonstrated=20
fairly solid bite inhibition in the first four cases, these were =
resolved easily=20
with basic, commonsense people education and dog training.&nbsp; =
However, in the=20
fifth case, the dog was euthanized and the child was physically and =
mentally=20
scarred for life.&nbsp; The dog had obviously not been socialized with =
children,=20
but more damning, the dog had very little bite inhibition at all.&nbsp; =
When=20
bite inhibition is poor or nonexistent, if and when the dog bites, in =
addition=20
to the serious injury caused to the victim, invariably the dog loses its =
life=20
and the owner loses a companion, peace of mind and often a=20
lawsuit.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>INHIBIT FORCE BEFORE FREQUENCY<BR>A puppy's =
needle-sharp teeth=20
and its often rapacious penchant for biting are essential for the =
establishment=20
of bite inhibition and the development of a soft mouth.&nbsp; Puppy =
biting hurts=20
but seldom cases appreciable harm.&nbsp; In fact, puppy biting behavior =
is the=20
way a young pup learns its jaws can hurt.&nbsp; It is important puppies =
learn to=20
inhibit the force of their biting before they acquire the blunt yet =
formidable=20
teeth and strong jaws of an adolescent dog.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Although the abrupt and total curtailment of puppy =
biting (if=20
possible) offers immediate relief to most owners, it often reflects only =
a=20
short-term gain and does not always augur well for the future.&nbsp; If =
the=20
puppy is forbidden to bite, it will not have sufficient opportunity to =
learn=20
that its jaws may inflict pain.&nbsp; Thus, if it is ever provoked to =
bite as an=20
adult, the resultant bite is likely to be a hard one, causing severe=20
damage.&nbsp; Certainly puppy biting must be controlled, but only in a=20
progressive, systematic manner, whereby the pup is taught to inhibit the =
force=20
of its bites.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>To inform the puppy that biting hurts, it is not =
necessary to=20
hurt, frighten, punish or even reprimand the pup; a simple "Ouch!" is=20
sufficient.&nbsp; If the pup acknowledges the "ouch" and desists, praise =
and=20
resume playing but in a calmer manner. If the puppy ignores the =
reprimand,=20
emphasize "OOOUUCHH!" and exit pronto.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>LEARNING THROUGH PLAY<BR>As when playing with their =
littermates=20
or mom's teats and tail, puppies quickly learn hard bites lose =
playmates.&nbsp;=20
Return after one or two minutes time out and make up by having the puppy =
come,=20
sit and calm down before resuming play.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Once the pup's mouthing no longer hurts, pretend it =
does.&nbsp;=20
Greet harder munches with a yelp of pseudo-pain.&nbsp;&nbsp; The puppy =
will=20
begin to get the idea, thinking, "Whooahh! These humans are=20
super-sensitive.&nbsp; I'll have to be much more gentle."&nbsp; The =
force of the=20
puppy's biting will progressively decrease until biting becomes mouthing =
and=20
eventually, mouthing succumbs to gumming or slobbering.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile><I>Never</I> allow the puppy to mouth human hair or=20
clothing.&nbsp; Hair and clothing are not innervated and therefore can =
feel=20
neither pressure nor pain.&nbsp; Allowing a pup to mouth hair, scarves,=20
shoelaces or gloved hands inadvertently trains it to bite harder, =
extremely=20
close to human flesh!</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>Once the puppy's mouthing no longer exerts any palpable =
pressure=20
whatsoever, then and only then can you teach the pup to reduce the =
frequency of=20
its oral proclivities.&nbsp; Teach the meaning of "Off!" by hand-feeding =
kibble,=20
so the pup may learn very gentle mouthing is okay, but it must stop the =
instant=20
you say, "Off!"</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>And of course, allowing mouthing to resume is the best =
reward for=20
a puppy that stops mouthing on request.&nbsp; At this stage the puppy, =
or young=20
adolescent dog, should never be allowed to initiate mouthing (unless =
requested=20
to do so).</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>NIP IT IN THE BUD<BR>Some dogs learn to inhibit the =
force and=20
frequency of biting quickly and naturally, whereas for other dogs bite=20
inhibition must be actively taught as a specific exercise.&nbsp; After =
just a=20
few weeks of instruction, the "mouthy" breeds and their puppies from =
hell=20
characteristically curtail hard biting fairly quickly, since the owner =
is=20
immediately aware of the problem and takes appropriate action and the =
puppy has=20
more than ample opportunity to learn its biting hurts.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>It may seem paradoxical, but puppies that are mouthing =
maniacs=20
and/or puppies that grow up with children are much more likely to =
develop gentle=20
jaws and a soft mouth as an adult.&nbsp; On the other hand, shy, =
reserved and=20
/or fearful dogs, which often do not play as much and therefore seldom=20
roughhouse or bite their owners, and breeds that have been bred to have =
soft=20
mouths, seldom present much of a puppy problem to their owners and =
therefore do=20
not receive sufficient feedback concerning the power of their=20
jaws.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile>All too often, when a dog has bitten severely the case =
history=20
reveals the dog was "fine" as a puppy.&nbsp; This is the major reason we =
go to=20
great pains to encourage shy and standoffish dogs to play in puppy =
class.&nbsp;=20
The most important survival lesson for a puppy to learn is that when it =
bites,=20
it causes pain.&nbsp; Of course, the pup can only learn this lessen if =
it bites=20
and if the bitee gives appropriate feedback.</FONT></B></P>
<P style=3D"MARGIN-LEFT: 100px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 100px" =
align=3Dleft><B><FONT size=3D4=20
face=3DEurostile><BR><I>Many of these exercises are demonstrated in Ian =
Dunbar's=20
"Sirius Puppy Training" video and described in detail in his "Preventing =

Aggression" booklet, available from James &amp; Kenneth Publishers, =
Berkeley,=20
California.</I></FONT></B></P></FONT></DIV></BODY></HTML>

------=_NextPart_000_05A5_01CA56E0.0ADE3C00--

